Quick answer
Some of it is fair. "Boring for good" isn't proven. This month, Japanese forum threads and at least one blog are asking a blunt question: has ONE PIECE become boring? The complaints are specific, and some of them hold up against the numbers:
- Elbaf is long. It started in chapter 1126 and is 73 chapters in after 1198. That is already longer than Skypiea (66) or Egghead (68), and close to Whole Cake Island (78).
- Breaks are frequent. ONE PIECE was off 3 times in the 12 weeks of Weekly Shonen Jump up to issue 52.
- But Wano took 149 chapters, was called slow at the time, and many readers rate it far higher now.
Our verdict: "too long" and "too many breaks" are fair complaints. "ONE PIECE is boring now" is a mood, not a fact, and chapter 1198 ended on two big hooks.
OUR TAKE. The complaints are summarised from Japanese blogs and forum threads posted after each chapter's official release (dates in the sources). Forum posts are anonymous opinions, not polls: we report where they come from and don't treat them as "what Japan thinks". Chapter counts are CHAPTER-REFERENCED from two arc guides; break weeks are from our own release tracker. No leaks.
Fair complaints
- Elbaf is long: 73 chapters so far, more than Skypiea or Egghead
- Breaks are frequent: 3 in the 12 weeks to issue 52
- A reported 2026 promise hasn't landed yet
Not proven
- "ONE PIECE has become boring" for good
- The writing has fallen apart
- The foreshadowing will never pay off
What Japanese readers are saying
The same few complaints come up again and again in November's threads and blogs:
- "Elbaf has gone on too long." A forum thread from 15–16 November compares it with Skypiea, an arc often criticised as slow, and counts "about 70 chapters" so far. Another calls it "Elbaf's third year".
- "The dialogue is hard to read." A thread after chapter 1197 picks apart the wording, and some blame the editing.
- "Foreshadowing, no payoff." New terms and mysteries keep arriving, and readers say few are resolved.
- "Flashbacks instead of adventure." One blogger, writing on 15 November, says they wanted to explore Elbaf, and got mostly flashbacks and a kidnapping plot. They still call the flashbacks fun, and say the problem is how hard the story has become to follow, not that it's dull.
The pushback is there too. In the same threads, readers point out that Wano and Skypiea were both called slow while they ran, and are rated far higher now.
What the numbers say
Elbaf against other big arcs: (CHAPTER-REFERENCED; arc boundaries vary by a chapter between guides)
| Arc | Chapters | Length |
|---|---|---|
| Skypiea | 237–302 | 66 |
| Egghead | 1058–1125 | 68 |
| Elbaf (so far) | 1126–1198 | 73 |
| Whole Cake Island | 825–902 | 78 |
| Wano | 909–1057 | 149 |
So "too long" is fair, but not unprecedented. Elbaf is already ONE PIECE's longest arc since Wano, and it isn't over. Wano was twice as long.
Breaks, from our tracker: across Weekly Shonen Jump issues 41 to 52 (September to November 2026), ONE PIECE ran 7 chapters (1192–1198), with 1199 scheduled for issue 52, and was off 3 times (issues 45, 48 and 51), plus one week with no magazine. Two of the three runs were two chapters long. The full table.
That changes how an arc feels. Seventy-three chapters with a break every two or three weeks takes far longer in real life than the chapter count suggests, and some cliffhangers wait twice as long.
Oda's "2026" promise
Japanese forums are recirculating a comment said to be from Jump Festa: Oda reportedly said 2026 would end Elbaf with a bang and head for Laugh Tale at top speed.
We couldn't find the original wording. It appears only in forum summaries, which place it at Jump Festa. Until we can read it in an official source, treat the exact promise as reported, not confirmed.
Either way, the frustration is real: with weeks of 2026 left, Elbaf is still going, and that is what the threads are reacting to.
The case for patience
- Wano was called slow too. It ran 149 chapters. Readers in this month's threads point out it was criticised while it ran, and many rate it far higher now.
- 1198 just set up two big hooks. Imu admits it is on a clock, and a giant says Luffy "turned into something"; a strange creature in the West Village may be him. Is Imu dying? · Is the black monkey Luffy?
Our verdict on each complaint
| Complaint | Fair? |
|---|---|
| Elbaf is too long | 7/10. Longest arc since Wano, and not finished. |
| There are too many breaks | 6/10. 3 in the 12 weeks to issue 52; the numbers back it. |
| The dialogue is hard to follow | 4/10. Real for some readers, but it's taste. |
| The foreshadowing never pays off | 3/10. Too early to say; the arc isn't over. |
| ONE PIECE is boring now | 3/10. A mood after a long arc, not a trend we can measure. |
What would change our minds
- Chapter 1199, out on Shonen Jump+ at 00:00 JST on Monday 23 November (times in your zone). If it resolves the Imu and "monkey" hooks with real momentum, the mood can turn fast.
- The break note on its last page. Another break straight away will feed the complaints.
- An end date for Elbaf, from Oda or Shueisha.
Read next
